Template:MainPageCaseDescription: Difference between revisions

From Censorpedia

No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 2: Line 2:
----
----
<onlyinclude>
<onlyinclude>
====Date: [[:Category:2016|2016]]====
====Date: [[:Category:1994|1994]]====


====Region: [[:Category:North America|North America]]====
====Region: [[:Category:North America|North America]]====


====Subject: [[:Category:Political/Economic/Social Opinion|Political/Economic/Social Opinion]], [[:Category:Nudity|Nudity]]====
====Subject: [[:Category:Religion|Religion]]====


====Medium: [[:Category:Photography|Photography]], [[:Category:Mixed Media|Mixed Media]], [[:Category:Public Art|Public Art]]====
====Medium: [[:Sculpture|Sculpture]]====
----
----
[[File:050716statenislandconsent.jpg|thumb|link=Susan_E._Wagner_High_School_students'_anti-rape_art]]
[[File:Hello_Kitty.jpg|right|200 pixels|frame|Image is from a hello kitty enthusiast's blog]]
'''Artist:''' Andrea Gonzalez, Meghan Callahan-Scarcella
'''Artist:''' Tom Sachs


'''Confronting Bodies:''' Susan E. Wagner High School
'''Confronting Bodies:''' Barney's Department Store


'''Dates of Action:''' May 2016
'''Dates of Action:''' 1994


'''Location:''' Susan E. Wagner High School, Staten Island, NY
'''Location:''' New York, NY


'''Description of Artwork:''' For a student exhibition in the lobby of Susan E. Wagner High School in Staten Island, Meghan Callahan-Scarcella and Andrea Gonzalez, classmates and best friends, collaborated on a photo-collage project to address sexual consent and rape culture. Callahan-Scarcella shot a photograph of the bare back of Gonzalez, and they superimposed texts such as "No Means No," "You Don't Own Me," "My Body, My Rules," and so on.
'''Description of Artwork:''' The sculpture ''Hello Kitty Nativity Scene'' depicts a traditional nativity scene, however replaces the traditional characters with pop-culture representations. In the piece, the three kings were replaced with Bart Simpson figures and the Virgin Mary and baby Jesus with Hello Kitty dolls.  


'''The Incident:''' The photo-collage was removed from the exhibition due to its depiction of Gonzalez's bare back. Students and parents alike were outraged by the artwork's removal. (May 11): NCAC sent a letter of protest to the school's principal.
'''The Incident:''' The sculpture was entered into an auction sponsored by Barney's department store in New York City.  Hundreds of artists' works were displayed in Barney's front window. After two weeks the president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights, William Donohue, warned the store to removed the sculpture and contacted the media, accusing the work of blasphemy.  Barney's received hundreds of phone calls calling for the piece's removal following the radio announcement.


'''Results of Incident:''' To protest the censorship, students circulated a petition at school, and then an online petition was created. At first, the administration justified removal of the work with the bizarre claim that it was a violation of the school's dress code. Later, in a meeting with Student Government, Principal Giordano explained that the age of the model in the photograph (Gonzalez is 15) was his reason for removing it, despite the fact the image is patently non-obscene and non-pornographic. Callahan-Scarcella and Gonzalez later agreed to re-shoot the photograph with Gonzalez wearing a t-shirt, using the same messages. The revised work was returned to the exhibition.
'''Results of Incident:''' Sachs' sculpture was removed from the window display. Barney's Senior Vice President for Creative Services, Simon Doonan, took responsibility for the display, calling it his "error in judgement."


'''Source:''' http://www.silive.com/news/index.ssf/2016/05/susan_wagner_students_react_to.html, [http://ncac.org/letters/staten-island-high-school-art-students-told-to-clothe-their-anti-rape-artwork Staten Island High School Art Students Told to Clothe their Anti-Rape Artwork, MAY 9, 2016]
'''Source:''' Artistic Freedom Under Attack, 1995
__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
__NOEDITSECTION__
__NOEDITSECTION__

Revision as of 15:22, 27 February 2023

Please add the case description between the two <onlyinclude> </onlyinclude> tags. The content (description) shown below will be shown on Main Page.


Date: 1994

Region: North America

Subject: Religion

Medium: Sculpture


Image is from a hello kitty enthusiast's blog

Artist: Tom Sachs

Confronting Bodies: Barney's Department Store

Dates of Action: 1994

Location: New York, NY

Description of Artwork: The sculpture Hello Kitty Nativity Scene depicts a traditional nativity scene, however replaces the traditional characters with pop-culture representations. In the piece, the three kings were replaced with Bart Simpson figures and the Virgin Mary and baby Jesus with Hello Kitty dolls.

The Incident: The sculpture was entered into an auction sponsored by Barney's department store in New York City. Hundreds of artists' works were displayed in Barney's front window. After two weeks the president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights, William Donohue, warned the store to removed the sculpture and contacted the media, accusing the work of blasphemy. Barney's received hundreds of phone calls calling for the piece's removal following the radio announcement.

Results of Incident: Sachs' sculpture was removed from the window display. Barney's Senior Vice President for Creative Services, Simon Doonan, took responsibility for the display, calling it his "error in judgement."

Source: Artistic Freedom Under Attack, 1995