Piss Christ: Difference between revisions
NCACintern (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
NCACintern (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
|date_of_action=October 12, 1997 | |date_of_action=October 12, 1997 | ||
|location=Victoria, Australia | |location=Victoria, Australia | ||
|description_of_content=The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. The photo itself is an image of a plastic crucifix inside a jar of yellow liquid, which the artist said | |description_of_content=The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. The photo itself is an image of a plastic crucifix inside a jar of yellow liquid, which the artist said was his own urine. Viewers often interpret the crucifix's immersion in bodily fluid as blasphemous, and it has attracted religiously-motivated censorship as a result. Yet Andres Serrano, the artist, views his work differently. | ||
|description_of_incident=The National Gallery of Victoria planned to exhibit a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition. On the first day of its opening weekend, the photograph was kicked by a 51-year-old man named John Allen Haywood, who went on to receive one month of jail time. His attack only partially damaged the frame, however, and the exhibition was set to continue when the next day, two teenagers, aged 16 and 18, staged one attack on a photo of a Ku Klux Klan member on an opposite wall, which sufficiently distracted the guards while the other destroyed | |||
“You could say, I’m a controversial artist by accident," he says. "I had no idea Piss Christ would get the attention it did, since I meant neither blasphemy nor offense by it. I’ve been a Catholic all my life, so I am a follower of Christ. But I’m an artist, and the role of the artist is to break new ground for himself and for his audience.” | |||
Explaining the work, Serrano argues his work is an accurate portrayal of a religiously-significant event: "What it symbolizes is the way Christ died: the blood came out of him but so did the piss and the shit. Maybe if Piss Christ upsets you, it's because it gives some sense of what the crucifixion actually was like." | |||
|description_of_incident=The National Gallery of Victoria planned to exhibit a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition. On the first day of its opening weekend, the photograph was kicked by a 51-year-old man named John Allen Haywood, who went on to receive one month of jail time. His attack only partially damaged the frame, however, and the exhibition was set to continue when the next day, two teenagers, aged 16 and 18, staged one attack on a photo of a Ku Klux Klan member on an opposite wall, which sufficiently distracted the guards while the other destroyed Serrano’s work. | |||
|description_of_result=Shortly afterward, the exhibit was shut down by the museum art director Dr. Timothy Potts, who cited "the safety of the gallery and its staff." | |description_of_result=Shortly afterward, the exhibit was shut down by the museum art director Dr. Timothy Potts, who cited "the safety of the gallery and its staff." | ||
|image=Piss Christ by Serrano Andres (1987).jpg | |image=Piss Christ by Serrano Andres (1987).jpg | ||
|source=http://www.artcrimes.net/piss-christ | |source=http://www.artcrimes.net/piss-christ, https://www.vice.com/en/article/9ag9jz/trump-torture-and-a-killer-clown-inside-provocateur-andres-serranos-latest-exhibition | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{Display censorship incident | {{Display censorship incident | ||
| Line 24: | Line 28: | ||
|date_of_action=April 17, 2011 | |date_of_action=April 17, 2011 | ||
|location=Avignon, France | |location=Avignon, France | ||
|description_of_content=The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. | |description_of_content=The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. Piss Christ, the formal title of which is "Immersion," offers the visual of a crucifix suspended in a body of amber-colored urine. | ||
|description_of_incident=An Avignon museum sought to display a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition called "I Believe in Miracles." After an 800-person protest earlier that day by conservative Christians outside of the museum, an assailant attacked the photograph with a hammer and either a pick-axe or a screwdriver, effectively destroying the work. | |description_of_incident=An Avignon museum sought to display a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition called "I Believe in Miracles." After an 800-person protest earlier that day by conservative Christians outside of the museum, an assailant attacked the photograph with a hammer and either a pick-axe or a screwdriver, effectively destroying the work. | ||
|description_of_result=The museum continued the exhibition and displayed the damaged work. | |description_of_result=The museum continued the exhibition and displayed the damaged work. | ||
| Line 41: | Line 45: | ||
|location=Santa Barbara, California, USA | |location=Santa Barbara, California, USA | ||
|description_of_content=Serrano's photograph presents an image of a crucifix submerged in urine—which the artist claimed was his own. | |description_of_content=Serrano's photograph presents an image of a crucifix submerged in urine—which the artist claimed was his own. | ||
|description_of_incident=The Santa Barbara Unified School District (SBUSD) attracted controversy for including "Immersion (Piss Christ)" in the curriculum of one of its high school | |description_of_incident=The Santa Barbara Unified School District (SBUSD) attracted controversy for including Andres Serrano's "Immersion (Piss Christ)" in the curriculum of one of its high school "Theory of Knowledge" courses at Dos Pueblos High School. A Catholic law firm, The Thomas More Society, sent the school district a letter on May 9, 2023, demanding the work be removed from the course, claiming it was "illegal" and anti-Catholic "bigotry." | ||
"The 'Piss Christ' image is hate-speech which is intended to, and which actually does, cause devout Catholics to feel directly harassed and targeted," the letter read. "The image is meant to provoke a reaction, it is meant to be harassing. In that sense, it may be “art,” but teaching it is no different than asking students to personally step on a crucifix so that the class can then have a discussion about how engaging in blasphemy made them feel." | "The 'Piss Christ' image is hate-speech which is intended to, and which actually does, cause devout Catholics to feel directly harassed and targeted," the letter read. "The image is meant to provoke a reaction, it is meant to be harassing. In that sense, it may be “art,” but teaching it is no different than asking students to personally step on a crucifix so that the class can then have a discussion about how engaging in blasphemy made them feel." | ||
|description_of_result=Attorneys from the Thomas More Society announced on June 7, 2023 that the school district promised | |description_of_result=Attorneys from the Thomas More Society announced their victory on June 7, 2023, sharing that the school district promised them "Piss Christ" would no longer be used in the "Theory of Knowledge" course moving forwards. | ||
|source=https://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/piss-christ-removed-from-california-school-curriculum-following-outrage-santa-barbara-unified-district-dos-pueblos-high-thomas-more-society-andres-serrano | |source=https://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/piss-christ-removed-from-california-school-curriculum-following-outrage-santa-barbara-unified-district-dos-pueblos-high-thomas-more-society-andres-serrano | ||
}} | }} | ||
Latest revision as of 17:41, 13 July 2023
.jpg)
Artist: Andres Serrano
Year: 1997
Date of Action: October 12, 1997
Region:
Location: Victoria, Australia
Subject: Religion
Medium: Photography
Confronting Bodies: John Allen Haywood, Two unnamed teenagers, Dr. Timothy Potts
Description of Artwork: The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. The photo itself is an image of a plastic crucifix inside a jar of yellow liquid, which the artist said was his own urine. Viewers often interpret the crucifix's immersion in bodily fluid as blasphemous, and it has attracted religiously-motivated censorship as a result. Yet Andres Serrano, the artist, views his work differently.
“You could say, I’m a controversial artist by accident," he says. "I had no idea Piss Christ would get the attention it did, since I meant neither blasphemy nor offense by it. I’ve been a Catholic all my life, so I am a follower of Christ. But I’m an artist, and the role of the artist is to break new ground for himself and for his audience.”
Explaining the work, Serrano argues his work is an accurate portrayal of a religiously-significant event: "What it symbolizes is the way Christ died: the blood came out of him but so did the piss and the shit. Maybe if Piss Christ upsets you, it's because it gives some sense of what the crucifixion actually was like."
The Incident: The National Gallery of Victoria planned to exhibit a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition. On the first day of its opening weekend, the photograph was kicked by a 51-year-old man named John Allen Haywood, who went on to receive one month of jail time. His attack only partially damaged the frame, however, and the exhibition was set to continue when the next day, two teenagers, aged 16 and 18, staged one attack on a photo of a Ku Klux Klan member on an opposite wall, which sufficiently distracted the guards while the other destroyed Serrano’s work.
Results of Incident: Shortly afterward, the exhibit was shut down by the museum art director Dr. Timothy Potts, who cited "the safety of the gallery and its staff."
Source:
• http://www.artcrimes.net/piss-christ,
• https://www.vice.com/en/article/9ag9jz/trump-torture-and-a-killer-clown-inside-provocateur-andres-serranos-latest-exhibition
Artist: Andres Serrano
Year: 2011
Date of Action: April 17, 2011
Region: Europe
Location: Avignon, France
Subject: Religion
Medium: Photography
Confronting Bodies: An Unnamed Vandal
Description of Artwork: The photograph is a part of a series exploring fluids, such as blood, milk, urine and semen. Piss Christ, the formal title of which is "Immersion," offers the visual of a crucifix suspended in a body of amber-colored urine.
The Incident: An Avignon museum sought to display a print of the photograph as a part of an exhibition called "I Believe in Miracles." After an 800-person protest earlier that day by conservative Christians outside of the museum, an assailant attacked the photograph with a hammer and either a pick-axe or a screwdriver, effectively destroying the work.
Results of Incident: The museum continued the exhibition and displayed the damaged work.
Artist: Andres Serrano
Year: 2023
Date of Action: May 9, 2023
Region: North America
Location: Santa Barbara, California, USA
Subject: Religion
Medium: Photography
Confronting Bodies: The Thomas More Society
Description of Artwork: Serrano's photograph presents an image of a crucifix submerged in urine—which the artist claimed was his own.
The Incident: The Santa Barbara Unified School District (SBUSD) attracted controversy for including Andres Serrano's "Immersion (Piss Christ)" in the curriculum of one of its high school "Theory of Knowledge" courses at Dos Pueblos High School. A Catholic law firm, The Thomas More Society, sent the school district a letter on May 9, 2023, demanding the work be removed from the course, claiming it was "illegal" and anti-Catholic "bigotry."
"The 'Piss Christ' image is hate-speech which is intended to, and which actually does, cause devout Catholics to feel directly harassed and targeted," the letter read. "The image is meant to provoke a reaction, it is meant to be harassing. In that sense, it may be “art,” but teaching it is no different than asking students to personally step on a crucifix so that the class can then have a discussion about how engaging in blasphemy made them feel."
Results of Incident: Attorneys from the Thomas More Society announced their victory on June 7, 2023, sharing that the school district promised them "Piss Christ" would no longer be used in the "Theory of Knowledge" course moving forwards.
