Template:MainPageCaseDescription: Difference between revisions

From Censorpedia

No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 2: Line 2:
----
----
<onlyinclude>
<onlyinclude>
====Date: [[:Category:2017|2017]]====
====Date: [[:Category:2016|2016]]====


====Region: [[:Category:Middle East|Middle East]]====
====Region: [[:Category:North America|North America]]====


====Subject: [[:Category:Political/Economic/Social Opinion|Political/Economic/Social Opinion]]====
====Subject: [[:Category:Political/Economic/Social Opinion|Political/Economic/Social Opinion]]====


====Medium: [[:Category:Literature|Literature]]====
====Medium: [[:Public Art|Public Art]]====
----
----
[[File:Jareema-fee-ramallah-ghelaf.jpg|thumb|link=Crime_in_Ramallah]]
[[File:100px-Free_the_Water.jpg|thumb|link=Free_the_Water_(Detroit_Graffiti_artists)]]
'''Artist:''' Abbad Yahya
'''Artist:''' Antonio Cosme and William Lucka


'''Confronting Bodies:''' Palestinian Attorney General
'''Confronting Bodies:''' City of Detroit


'''Dates of Action:''' February 2017
'''Dates of Action:''' August-October 2016


'''Location:''' Palestine
'''Location:''' Detroit, MI


'''Description of Artwork:''' ''Crime in Ramallah'' is the fourth book by novelist Abbad Yahya. It follows the lives of three young Palestinian men, one of whom is gay, caught up in the murder of a young woman in the city of Ramallah.
'''Description of Artwork:''' In 2014, two Detroit artist-activists, Antonio Cosme and William Lucka, painted the politically motivated graffiti slogan, FREE THE WATER, along with a fist of resistance on a Highland Park water tower. Cosme and Lucka are outspoken critics of Detroit's redevelopment scheme and the water shut-offs that continue to plague the city. The shut-offs have stirred widespread protests because they disproportionately affect the city's poorest residents.


'''The Incident:''' The novel's inclusion of sex, masturbation and homosexuality made it controversial. The Palestinian Attorney General banned the book, moving to prosecute writer Abbad Yahya, banning his novel and accusing him of threatening morality and public decency, is a gross violation of his right to freedom of expression.  
'''The Incident:''' In August, 2016, the artists faced fines of up to $75,000 and a maximum jail sentence of four years on charges related to the malicious destruction of property and trespassing. Hyperallergic reported: 'In November 2014, police confronted Cosme and Lucka at the bottom of the tower, but nearly a year and a half had passed before police contacted them again about the incident. Then, a Detroit graffiti task force — a newly formed special unit charged with tracking and prosecuting taggers and graffiti artists — took over the case, claiming the cost of cleaning the tower would range from $45,000 to $75,000, Cosme says. Police raided Lucka’s home, taking many of his art-related materials, and eventually brought a slew of new charges against him, using one of the task force’s key tools: an expanding graffiti database. Cosme describes it as a “badass” archive of local street art despite its nefarious purpose. Using the database, the task force linked Lucka to multiple appearances of the tag “Astro,” which appeared on the water tower with “Free the Water.”'


Since the launch of the AG’s investigation, Yahya has been the victim of a hate campaign on social media, receiving death threats; copies of his novel were reportedly burnt in the Gaza strip.
'''Results of Incident:''' 10/25/16: The Free the Water Defense Campaign announced that artists Cosme and Lucka reached an out of court settlement with the state prior to their October 24th trial. A http://freethewater313.org news release reports: "Thanks to widespread community support and media coverage…[the artists] hammered out an arrangement for 1 year of nonreporting probation and 120 hours of community service each."


'''Results of Incident:''' Abbad Yahya remained in Qatar following the confiscation of his book, as he feared that he would be arrested if he returned home. English PEN released a statement supporting the author, pointing out the problematic censoring actions of the Palestinian government. In addition to this statement, The department of culture and information of the Palestine Liberation Organization also condemned the actions of the Attorney General's office, saying that it "opens the door for an endless censorship, which violates freedom of expression and right to creative writing."
'''Source:''' [http://us13.campaign-archive2.com/?u=e77a0c938f19df0639a65ece6&id=c488c1f05c&e=bcaa9a14bb Settlement Negotiated!]


A book club in the West Bank city of Nablus canceled a public discussion on ''Crime in Ramallah'' after its members received anonymous death threats.
[http://ncac.org/blog/detroit-artists-face-felony-charges-for-protest-graffiti Detroit Artists Face Felony Charges for Protest Graffiti], AUGUST 24, 2016


Hamas also condemned the novel, and the head of the Palestinian writers' union criticized it. However, prominent Palestinian intellectuals have demanded that the ban be rescinded.
[http://freethewater313.org/ Free the Water] campaign


'''Source:''' [https://www.englishpen.org/campaigns/palestine-abbad-yahya-under-investigation-for-threatening-morality-and-has-books-banned/ Palestine: Abbad Yahya under investigation for ‘threatening morality’ and has books banned], English PEN Statement
[http://hyperallergic.com/316946/two-detroit-artists-face-up-to-four-years-in-prison-for-political-graffiti Two Detroit Artists Face Up to Four Years in Prison for Political Graffiti], by Matthew Irwin, Hyperallergic, August 12, 2016


[https://arablit.org/2017/02/17/pen-issues-statement-about-case-against-palestinian-author-abbad-yahya-and-his-crime-in-ramallah/ PEN Issues Statement About Case Against Palestinian Author Abbad Yahya and His ‘Crime in Ramallah’], ArabLit, Feb 2, 2017
[http://artreport.com/apparently-painting-free-the-water-on-a-water-tower-can-land-you-jail-time Apparently Painting “Free The Water” On A Water Tower Can Land You Jail Time], by Bridget Casey, Art report, AUGUST, 2016


[https://www.alaraby.co.uk/english/society/2017/2/8/palestinian-authorities-ban-crime-in-ramallah-novel-over-indecency Palestinian authorities ban 'Crime in Ramallah' novel over 'indecency'], The New Arab, 2/8/2017
[https://www.theodysseyonline.com/freethewater-detroit-artists-fight-felony-charges-and-prison-time  #FreeTheWater: Detroit Artists Fight Felony Charges and Prison Time] by Brenda Montaña Aguilar, The Odyssey, July 19, 2016


[https://advox.globalvoices.org/2017/02/15/palestinian-authority-bans-novel-for-threatening-morality-and-public-decency/ Palestinian Authority Bans Novel for ‘Threatening Morality and Public Decency’], Global Voices,14 February 2017
[http://www.democracynow.org/2016/7/14/headlines/detroit_artists_fight_felonies_for_painting_free_the_water_on_tower Detroit: Artists Fight Felonies for Painting "Free the Water" on Tower], Democracy Now, JULY 14, 2016


[https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/04/01/521094950/facing-death-threats-and-a-ban-on-his-novel-a-palestinian-author-flees Facing Death Threats And A Ban On His Novel, A Palestinian Author Flees], NPR, April 1, 2017
[http://motorcitymuckraker.com/2016/04/18/water-shutoff-activists-face-possible-jail-time-for-free-the-water-mural Water shutoff activists face possible jail time for ‘Free the Water’ mural], by Steve Neavling, Motor City Muckraker, April 18, 2016
 
[https://www.wordswithoutborders.org/article/july-2017-divided-countries-crime-in-ramallah-abbad-yahyah-ruth-ahmedzal An excerpt from Crime in Ramallah: Noor’s Story], Words Without Borders Magazine, July 2017 issue
</onlyinclude>
</onlyinclude>
__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
__NOEDITSECTION__
__NOEDITSECTION__

Revision as of 15:52, 30 January 2023

Please add the case description between the two <onlyinclude> </onlyinclude> tags. The content (description) shown below will be shown on Main Page.


Date: 2016

Region: North America

Subject: Political/Economic/Social Opinion

Medium: Public Art


Artist: Antonio Cosme and William Lucka

Confronting Bodies: City of Detroit

Dates of Action: August-October 2016

Location: Detroit, MI

Description of Artwork: In 2014, two Detroit artist-activists, Antonio Cosme and William Lucka, painted the politically motivated graffiti slogan, FREE THE WATER, along with a fist of resistance on a Highland Park water tower. Cosme and Lucka are outspoken critics of Detroit's redevelopment scheme and the water shut-offs that continue to plague the city. The shut-offs have stirred widespread protests because they disproportionately affect the city's poorest residents.

The Incident: In August, 2016, the artists faced fines of up to $75,000 and a maximum jail sentence of four years on charges related to the malicious destruction of property and trespassing. Hyperallergic reported: 'In November 2014, police confronted Cosme and Lucka at the bottom of the tower, but nearly a year and a half had passed before police contacted them again about the incident. Then, a Detroit graffiti task force — a newly formed special unit charged with tracking and prosecuting taggers and graffiti artists — took over the case, claiming the cost of cleaning the tower would range from $45,000 to $75,000, Cosme says. Police raided Lucka’s home, taking many of his art-related materials, and eventually brought a slew of new charges against him, using one of the task force’s key tools: an expanding graffiti database. Cosme describes it as a “badass” archive of local street art despite its nefarious purpose. Using the database, the task force linked Lucka to multiple appearances of the tag “Astro,” which appeared on the water tower with “Free the Water.”'

Results of Incident: 10/25/16: The Free the Water Defense Campaign announced that artists Cosme and Lucka reached an out of court settlement with the state prior to their October 24th trial. A http://freethewater313.org news release reports: "Thanks to widespread community support and media coverage…[the artists] hammered out an arrangement for 1 year of nonreporting probation and 120 hours of community service each."

Source: Settlement Negotiated!

Detroit Artists Face Felony Charges for Protest Graffiti, AUGUST 24, 2016

Free the Water campaign

Two Detroit Artists Face Up to Four Years in Prison for Political Graffiti, by Matthew Irwin, Hyperallergic, August 12, 2016

Apparently Painting “Free The Water” On A Water Tower Can Land You Jail Time, by Bridget Casey, Art report, AUGUST, 2016

#FreeTheWater: Detroit Artists Fight Felony Charges and Prison Time by Brenda Montaña Aguilar, The Odyssey, July 19, 2016

Detroit: Artists Fight Felonies for Painting "Free the Water" on Tower, Democracy Now, JULY 14, 2016

Water shutoff activists face possible jail time for ‘Free the Water’ mural, by Steve Neavling, Motor City Muckraker, April 18, 2016